Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate 13 Nov 2015 2015-11-13 2015-11-13 /images/medium/future-proof-sponsors-the-ads-we-dont-hate-1.jpeg advertising, podcast advertising podcast 2015 Amidst all the hand-wringing over ad blocking and intrusive tracking, there’s one set of advertisers that supports the independent Internet with ads that people... 1
Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate

Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate

Amidst all the hand-wringing over ad blocking and intrusive tracking, there’s one set of advertisers that supports the independent Internet with ads that people actually kinda like.

There are a certain set of companies and brands that seem like “podcast advertisers” — if you’ve ever heard someone stammer their way through “Mail…kimp?” you know exactly the ones we’re talking about. Squarespace and Audible and Stamps.com and a bunch of other companies that seem to exist in a world outside of glossy magazine ads or prime time television commercials or even regular online banner ads.

Even though these companies sometimes do more traditional campaigns (Squarespace has done ads in subway stations and even in-theater advertising before movies), they’re often defined through “sponsor reads”, with podcast hosts carefully reciting promotional discount codes. That’s striking given that their competitors are usually spending their money on slicker, highly-produced conventional ads or the functional, utilitarian text ads on Google and Facebook. When they do venture into graphical ads, it’s usually on small, tasteful, boutique ad networks like The Deck.

The end result? There are some companies that have an advertising presence online that people don’t hate, and actually sometimes really appreciate. Maybe we could call these companies “future-proof sponsors”, the ones who won’t have their ad strategy threatened by ad blockers or a backlash against tracking, and who in turn help smaller concerns on the web stay afloat.

These future-proof sponsors came to mind this summer when my cofounder Gina and I were working on Makerbase, our community site that’s sort of like IMDb for people who make apps or websites. We realized we wanted to support the site with sponsorships so it could be freely accessible to everybody, but only if the sponsors were really good and the sponsorships wouldn’t ruin the site over time. Both of us have spent enough time working on sites supported by regular web advertising to know how often that can harm the user experience.

That requirement led to doing some research into these kind of sponsors. From a business standpoint, it’s hard to say how big the future-proof sponsor market is; a generous definition might include a few hundred companies and products, most with a total ad budget of under a million dollars a year. That adds up to maybe a few hundred million dollars in spending across the entire category, less than half a percent of the overall online advertising market. Yet despite that small share of the overall market, these are the companies that are best poised to weather any storms around ad blockers or malware being distributed through ad networks, and to come out with both customers and publishers on their side.

These are the companies that are best poised to weather any storms around ad blockers.

So what’s holding them back? Right now, there isn’t much infrastructure. There are no big, dominant podcasting ad networks the way there are for graphical ads. (That’s probably a good thing — the centralization of the text ad and display ad markets led to the creepy, overbearing optimization tools that have fueled an ad tech arms race at the expense of users.)

There’s also no way for an advertiser who wants to support independent sites to really see what’s out there and connect to all the sites they might want to sponsor. It’s easy enough to buy ads on The Deck but that may mean a sponsor still overlooks Fusion Ads. It’s obvious that a brand might want to sponsor podcasts by Gimlet Media, but they might forget about the Maximum Fun or Loud Speakers networks. And if a company wants to work with sponsorships that are unique to a site, like Daring Fireball’s RSS feed sponsorships, or our own “made with” buttons on Makerbase, there’s no way to learn that they exist or how they work, without going site-by-site to find out.

Tweet from @anildash, November 12, 2015


So there’s an opportunity here, but we’re not quite sure what it is yet. Maybe we need a way for independent sites to promote each other’s sponsorship offerings, and make it easier for sponsors to find us. Maybe we need a way for future-proof sponsors to make themselves known, to say that they want more opportunities to reach customers in a non-annoying way that means their brands will be welcome instead of merely tolerated. Maybe it’s all of the above.

But since our work with Makerbase is all about supporting creators, we know there’s a real opportunity here. This is something we need to help create because it makes the internet better for our users, and because a lot of the people who make apps and websites feel better about their work when they are supported by these kinds of future-proof sponsors. If you’re one of these sponsors, or make a site or podcast or publication that’s supported by them, we hope you’ll respond with your thoughts of what would help make this market run better.


If you make websites or apps, check out Makerbase: It’s a great way to share what you’ve made and find out about the latest creations from the people who inspire you.

Cite this post

APA
Dash, A. (2015, November 13). Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate. Anil Dash. https://anildash.com/2015/11/13/future-proof-sponsors-the-ads-we-dont-hate/
MLA
Dash, Anil. "Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate." Anil Dash, 13 Nov. 2015, anildash.com/2015/11/13/future-proof-sponsors-the-ads-we-dont-hate/. Accessed .
Chicago
Dash, Anil. "Future-proof sponsors & the ads we don’t hate." Anil Dash. November 13, 2015. Accessed . https://anildash.com/2015/11/13/future-proof-sponsors-the-ads-we-dont-hate/.